Caveat – It is increasingly common for parents, caregivers, and educators who follow us to reach out with questions about statements they’ve heard from others regarding technology and social media use. This article was inspired by one such parent who recently shared that a presenter claimed, with no research citation to support their statement, “youth phone addiction can lead to substance addiction.”
Parents and caregivers are constantly bombarded with warnings about the dangers of excessive cellphone use among youth – some are legit, but many others are nothing more than a moral panic. Some claim that what is often described as “addictive cellphone use” is a gateway to more serious addictions, including drug and alcohol addiction. But what does the research actually say?
To be very clear, there is no direct causal link between problematic cellphone use causing drug addiction – NONE! Current scientific literature does not establish a direct cause-and-effect relationship between excessive cellphone use and subsequent drug addiction. While some studies have found “some” correlations between problematic technology use and substance use disorders, correlation does not equal causation. (1)
However, what the research does emphasize – shared vulnerabilities, such as impulsivity and poor emotional regulation, may contribute to both excessive technology use and substance abuse, rather than one causing the other. (2)
What the research does suggest, individuals with addictive tendencies may engage in multiple compulsive behaviours, including excessive cellphone use and substance abuse. However, rather than viewing one as the cause of the other, experts encourage looking at underlying risk factors such as childhood trauma, poor impulse control, or co-occurring mental health disorders.
While it is important to monitor excessive technology use and encourage balance, current research does not support the claim that problematic cellphone use directly leads to drug addiction. Rather than relying on fear-based narratives, parents should focus on evidence-based approaches to foster digital wellness and overall well-being in their children.
To recap, the claim that excessive cellphone use leads to drug addiction is not supported by the good evidence-based research. While some studies indicate correlations between problematic technology use and substance abuse, correlation does not imply causation. Instead of viewing cellphone use as a direct gateway to drug addiction, experts emphasize the importance of addressing shared vulnerabilities such as impulsivity, poor emotional regulation, childhood trauma, and co-occurring mental health disorders.
For parents and caregivers, distinguishing between correlation and causation is crucial. When others overstate the dangers of cellphone use, it can lead to unnecessary fear, diverting attention from more significant risk factors associated with substance abuse. Rather than adopting fear-based narratives, a more effective approach is to promote digital wellness, healthy coping mechanisms, and open communication about responsible technology use. Encouraging balance and supporting children’s emotional and mental well-being will be far more beneficial than falsely equating problematic cellphone use as a gateway to substance addiction.
Related Article:
Digital Food For Thought
The White Hatter
Facts Not Fear, Facts Not Emotions, Enlighten Not Frighten, Know Tech Not No Tech
References:
