In today’s onlife world, protecting our children online is a top priority for many parents and caregivers. With the rise of child safety products and software designed to monitor online activities, track locations, and block inappropriate content, it’s tempting to rely on these tools to help keep our kids safer. However, there’s an emerging concern that parents need to be aware of – some of these child safety products and software are using the vast amounts of data they collect from their users to create public facing reports, that are often leveraged to promote and sell a vendor’s product. While this raises important questions about privacy, data security, and ethics that we will speak to in this article, it’s also worth recognizing the potential benefits of this data collection when handled responsibly.
Child safety products – ranging from phones, wearables, software, and apps that monitor social media usage often require access to extensive amounts of personal data to function effectively. This can include everything from browsing history, text messages, and app usage, to geolocation data and even biometric information. While these products promise to help parents keep their children safer, the data they collect is a goldmine for companies looking to generate detailed reports on trends, behaviors, and risks.
Some companies aggregate this data to create reports that highlight the dangers children face online, such as exposure to inappropriate content, cyberbullying, or online predators. These reports are frequently utilized in marketing materials, media campaigns, and sales pitches, either overtly or subtly through content marketing, to promote a vendor’s products as essential tools for modern parenting in today’s onlife world.
So, what are the potential benefits of this type of data collection?
- When companies collect and analyze data on how children interact with the onlife world, they can use this information to improve their products. For instance, by identifying common risks or threats, companies can refine their software to better protect children from specific dangers. This means that the products you use can become more effective over time as they learn from real-world data.
- The reports generated from user data can provide valuable insights into emerging trends and risks that parents may not be aware of. For example, if a report shows a spike in cyberbullying incidents on a particular platform, it can prompt parents to have important conversations with their children about safe online behavior on that platform. In this way, these reports can serve as early warning systems that help parents stay informed about new threats and concerns.
- Some companies use the data they collect to develop educational materials and resources for parents. By understanding the challenges that children face online, these companies can create content that is directly relevant to the issues at hand, helping parents better navigate the complexities of onlife parenting.
- The aggregated data from many users can contribute to broader industry-wide research, leading to advancements in child safety technology as a whole. When companies openly share their findings with researchers, educators, and policymakers, it can lead to better regulations, safer online environments, and more informed public discussions about children’s onlife safety.
So, why should parents also be cautious about this data collection?
Despite the potential benefits, the collection of sensitive data raises significant privacy concerns. Even if the data is anonymized, there’s still a risk that it could be misused, mishandled, or exposed in a data breach. Parents need to ask themselves – who has access to this data, and how secure is it? If a company is using your child’s data to create reports, you have the right to know how that data is being stored, protected, and shared. Some other concerns include:
- The reports generated from this data are often used to justify the need for these products. However, parents should approach these reports with caution. The companies producing them have a vested interest in highlighting the dangers that their products are designed to mitigate – like it or not, fear sells! This can lead to exaggerated claims or selective reporting that may not provide a fully accurate picture or context of the risks involved.
- When companies use data collected from their users to market their products, it can erode the trust that parents place in these tools. If parents begin to feel that their child’s safety is being used as a marketing tool, rather than the primary goal of the product, they may become skeptical of the product’s true intentions and effectiveness.
- Children are growing up in a world where their digital dossiers are being tracked from a young age. The data collected today could have long-term implications for their privacy and autonomy in the future. It’s essential for parents to consider the potential consequences of allowing companies to collect and use this data.
So, how can parents protect themselves and their children specific to this issue?
Before using any child safety product, it’s crucial to thoroughly research the company behind it. Start by examining their privacy policy, how they handle data, and whether they have a history of data breaches or privacy violations. When signing up, carefully review the terms and conditions to understand what data is being collected, how it will be used, and whether you can opt-out of certain data collection practices. For example, we encountered one vendor whose terms stated they use collected data for “upselling” their products and services, while another disclosed that they may collect sensitive information such as “racial or ethnic origin, political opinions or associations, religious or philosophical beliefs, trade union membership or associations, sexual orientation or practices, criminal record, or health or genetic information.” It’s important to question why a child safety product would need access to this type of sensitive data.
Unfortunately, privacy policies and terms of service are often difficult to read and comprehend. Another important question – does their product allow any Google product to access their platform or software? If they answer is yes, is this something you are comfortable with from a privacy standpoint?
Be critical of the reports generated by these companies, seek out independent academic peer-reviewed studies or reputable third-party research for a more balanced perspective on the risks and benefits of the tools they offer. Additionally, while technology can be a valuable tool for keeping kids safer, consider alternative foundational solutions such as open communication, teaching your children about digital literacy, and fostering a relationship of trust. These approaches can be just as effective in keeping your child safer, if not more so, than relying solely on software and devices.
While child safety products offer valuable tools for protecting our children in the onlife world, it’s essential for parents and caregivers to be aware of how their data is being used by these companies. The reports generated by these products can provide useful insights and improvements but should also be taken with a grain of salt. By staying informed, asking the right questions, and considering all aspects of your child’s safety, including their privacy, you can make more informed decisions about the tools you choose to use.
Digital Food For Thought
The White Hatter
Facts Not Fear, Fact Not Feelings, Enlighten Not Frighten, Know Tech Not No Tech
Related Articles:
